Oscar Nomination Reactions 2013

Oscar Nominations Day, it seems, is a day for me to wake up early, getting much less sleep than I otherwise would, because I’m excited to see the nominees as they’re announced. Every year, though, they make decisions that, at best, make me shake my head. This year, though, the Academy really outdid itself. If not for my sleeping roommate, there were have been much yelling (and perhaps even some expletive flinging) at some of this year’s head-scratchers.

Here are my reactions to the main categories. I have fewer thoughts on all of the others, so this should pretty much split the length up in half, with the second set of reactions coming out probably tomorrow sometime. For this post, I will also put my score (out of 100 for films; out of 5 for performances, directorial efforts, and screenplays) next to everything, as well as ranking them.

Best Picture Predictions:

1.      12 Years a Slave

2.      Gravity

3.      American Hustle

4.      The Wolf of Wall Street

5.      Nebraska

6.      Saving Mr. Banks

7.      Captain Phillips

8.      Her

9.      Inside Llewyn Davis

10.  Dallas Buyers Club

First Ones In: Blue Jasmine; August: Osage County

Other Alternates: Philomena; Before Midnight

Actual Best Picture:

1.      12 Years a Slave (97)-1

2.      American Hustle (56)-9

3.      Captain Phillips (88)-6

4.      Dallas Buyers Club (95)-3

5.      Gravity (91)-5

6.      Her (96)-2

7.      Nebraska (62)-8

8.      Philomena (78)-7

9.      The Wolf of Wall Street (94)-4

Score: 7/9

Reaction: If you stick to the Academy’s number of 9 nominees, then I got 7/9, or 8/9 if you allow me 10 prediction slots for 9 nominations. Anyway, that’s not all that bad, I don’t think, though last year I was perfect in this category, 9/9, with Moonrise Kingdom as my #10. That said, I am pretty ecstatic with the results here. Sure, I don’t think this category (or pretty much any of them for that reason) should be touching American Hustle or Nebraska with a 10-foot pole, but it was going to happen all along, so I’m not going to fight it (trust me, there’s much complaining to come on that front). Dallas Buyers Club getting in absolutely terrific, and while I’m disappointed I didn’t get Saving Mr. Banks right, I’m happier that Philomena was nominated as opposed to SMB. Very, very, very disappointed Inside Llewyn Davis failed to make it on, though.

Best Director Predictions:

1.      Steve McQueen for 12 Years a Slave

2.      Alfonso Cuarón for Gravity

3.      Martin Scorsese for The Wolf of Wall Street

4.      Paul Greengrass for Captain Phillips

5.      David O. Russell for American Hustle

First One In: Alexander Payne for Nebraska

Other Alternates: Spike Jonze for Her; Woody Allen for Blue Jasmine; J.C. Chandor for All Is Lost

Actual Best Director:

1.      Alfonso Cuarón for Gravity (5)-1

2.      Steve McQueen for 12 Years a Slave (5)-2

3.      Alexander Payne for Nebraska (2.5)-4

4.      David O. Russell for American Hustle (2)-5

5.      Martin Scorsese for The Wolf of Wall Street (5)-3

Score: 4/5

Reaction: Again, not a bad showing at all. Alexander Payne is an Academy darling, so I’m not surprised, even though I think his nomination, as well as Russell’s, is horrendous. Russell is such an absolute jerk that he deserves nothing, ever. I really liked his direction of Silver Linings Playbook, but here he shows his true colors. He has put Christopher Nolan in a headlock for trying to steal Jude Law for a movie (Jude Law? Seriously!). He also got into a fistfight with Clooney over his poor treatment of extras (I assume that was on Three Kings), and his fights with Lily Tomlin, which can be found on YouTube, are pretty bad. (All info courtesy of Louis Morgan (actoroscar.blogspot.com)). There were really only 6 legitimate contenders this year (sorry, Spike), and Greengrass’s hand-held, wobbly style is troubling to many, so his absence is understandable, and thus Payne gets on.

Best Actor Predictions:

1.      Chiwetel Ejiofor in 12 Years a Slave

2.      Matthew McConaughey in Dallas Buyers Club

3.      Tom Hanks in Captain Hanks

4.      Bruce Dern in Nebraska

5.      Robert Redford in All Is Lost

First One In: Christian Bale in American Hustle

Second One In: Leonardo DiCaprio in The Wolf of Wall Street

Third One In: Oscar Isaac in Inside Llewyn Davis

Other Alternates: Joaquin Phoenix in Her; Michael B. Jordan in Fruitvale Station; Forest Whitaker in Lee Daniels’ The Butler

Actual Best Actor:

1.      Christian Bale in American Hustle (3)-5

2.      Bruce Dern in Nebraska (4)-4

3.      Leonardo DiCaprio in The Wolf of Wall Street (5)-2

4.      Chiwetel Ejiofor in 12 Years a Slave (5)-3

5.       Matthew McConaughey in Dallas Buyers Club (5)-1

Score: 3/5

Reaction: This was very unfortunate. I have seen neither Hanks nor Redford, but I have not heard anything negative about any of them, and most things are quite positive, so it’s a shame that somebody so mediocre like Bale gets on. When I saw Cooper and then Bale get nominations, I knew American Hustle was in for making a killing, and they did. It’s a borderline terrible movie that is poorly directed, disgustingly overacted, horrendously underacted, and just plain bad. Not one “character-driven” moment seems authentic in any way, and much of the film, which should be continuously fun in the vein of the ‘70s heist it masquerades as, is terribly boring. Bale is fine, but does nothing with his character, which fortunately for him, is supposed to be a boring guy.

Best Actress Predictions:

1.      Cate Blanchett in Blue Jasmine

2.      Sandra Bullock in Gravity

3.      Emma Thompson in Saving Mr. Banks

4.      Judi Dench in Philomena

5.      Meryl Streep in August: Osage County

First One In: Amy Adams in American Hustle

Other Alternates: Brie Larson in Short Term 12; Adèle Exarchopoulos in Blue Is the Warmest Colour; Julie Delpy in Before Midnight

Actual Best Actress:

1.      Amy Adams in American Hustle (3.5)-3

2.      Cate Blanchett in Blue Jasmine (not seen)-N/A

3.      Sandra Bullock in Gravity (4.5)-1

4.      Judi Dench in Philomena (3.5)-2

5.      Meryl Streep in August: Osage County (not seen)-N/A

Score: 4/5

Reaction: It is very unfortunate that Emma Thompson got snubbed for Amy Adams’ performance and for Meryl Streep. Let’s be honest: Streep got on because she’s Streep (granted I haven’t seen her). Adams used to be my favorite lead member of Hustle’s cast, but the more I think about her, the more I dislike her. It’s unfortunate that Thompson, my current #2 for the year, got snubbed. Her film was so-so at times, but she was always great, lending much-needed depth to a sometimes idle script. Kristen Bell not even being in the conversation for her brilliant voice work in Frozen is understandable, but frustrating nonetheless.

Best Supporting Actor:

1.      Jared Leto in Dallas Buyers Club

2.      Michael Fassbender in 12 Years a Slave

3.      Barkhad Abdi in Captain Phillips

4.      Daniel Brühl in Rush

5.      James Gandolfini in Enough Said

First One In: Bradley Cooper in American Hustle

Second One In: Tom Hanks in Saving Mr. Banks

Third One In: Jonah Hill in The Wolf of Wall Street

Other Alternates: nobody really

Actual Best Supporting Actor:

1.      Barkhad Abdi in Captain Phillips (5)-2

2.      Bradley Cooper in American Hustle (2)-5

3.      Michael Fassbender in 12 Years a Slave (5)-1

4.      Jonah Hill in The Wolf of Wall Street (3)-4

5.      Jared Leto in Dallas Buyers Club (5)-3

Score: 3/5

Reaction: First, let’s get the snubs out of the way before I rage against the machine. I thought James Gandolfini would get on because he had the SAG nomination and because he died within the past year, but evidently playing completely against type (film type, evidently he was an immensely gentle and loving guy in real life) and dying isn’t good enough. Brühl, who I figured was a long shot at the beginning, got every single major prerequisite nomination. SAG, BAFTA, Globes. What else does a guy need? I haven’t seen Rush, which was completely shut-out surprisingly, so I can’t comment, but he’d be hard-pressed to be worse than Cooper. Hill was fine, and better than his Moneyball nomination, but he wasn’t worthy of his nomination. Cooper was horrendous. He played an off-the-wall character, but never figured out how to create an actual character. Instead, his outbursts have no backing in the personality he otherwise emits, which should have been an overly ambitious one. Everything about this performance is bad, and I’m toying with knocking him down to a 1.5 instead of a 2.

Best Supporting Actress Predictions:

1.      Lupita Nyong’o in 12 Years a Slave

2.      Jennifer Lawrence in American Hustle

3.      Julia Roberts in August: Osage County

4.      June Squibb in Nebraska

5.      Sally Hawkins in Blue Jasmine

First One In: Oprah Winfrey in Lee Daniels’ The Butler

Other Alternates: nobody, but there should be, especially Sarah Paulson and Alfre Woodard in 12 Years, Carey Mulligan in Inside Llewyn, Jennifer Garner in Dallas Buyers, and Margot Robbie in The Wolf.

Actual Best Supporting Actress:

1.      Lupita Nyong’o in 12 Years a Slave (5)-1

2.      Jennifer Lawrence in American Hustle (3.5)-3_

3.      Julia Roberts in August: Osage County (not seen)-N/A

4.      June Squibb in Nebraska (3.5)-2

5.      Sally Hawkins in Blue Jasmine (not seen)-N/A

Score: 5/5

Reaction: Checkmate, atheists! It’s a real shame I got all 5 in such a terribly weak category, though. Nyong’o was a shoo-in, but her co-star Sarah Paulson should have been, too. Roberts, sight unseen, is obviously a co-lead, but I’ve heard it might be her first semi-good performance, so kudos to her. Squibb is fine as the sassy old woman but adds little-to-no of the requisite emotional depth. Lawrence is sometimes overacting and sometimes entertaining, though she always just seems to be repeating her SLP performance when she is the latter. Perhaps worst of all, though, she is, at age 23, incredibly unconvincing as a woman who has supposedly been in a dead-end marriage for 10 years of so. Is terrible casting, and Lawrence does nothing to help it.

Best Adapted Screenplay:

1.      12 Years a Slave (John Ridley)

2.      The Wolf of Wall Street (Terence Winter)

3.      Philomena (Steve Coogan and Jeff Pope)

4.      Captain Phillips (Billy Ray)

5.      Before Midnight (Richard Linklater, Ethan Hawke, and Julie Delpy)

First One In: August: Osage County (Tracy Letts)

Second One In: Lone Survivor (Peter Berg)

Other Alternates: none that I can think of

Actual Best Adapted Screenplay:

1.      12 Years a Slave (John Ridley) (5)-2

2.      Before Midnight (Richard Linklater, Ethan Hawke, and Julie Delpy) (not seen)-N/A

3.      Captain Phillips (Billy Ray) (4-4.5)-4

4.      Philomena (Steve Coogan and Jeff Pope) (4.5)-3

5.      The Wolf of Wall Street (Terence Winter) (5)-1

Score: 5/5

Reaction: 2 perfects in a row. As far as I know, this is a very strong category, and the only film with the potential to be a better option than one of these is Frozen, which wasn’t even in the conversation, so what can you do.

Best Original Screenplay:

1.      American Hustle (Eric Warren Singer and David O. Russell)

2.      Her (Spike Jonze)

3.      Blue Jasmine (Woody Allen)

4.      Inside Llewyn Davis (Joel and Ethan Coen)

5.      Nebraska (Bob Nelson)

First One In: Dallas Buyers Club

Second One In: Enough Said (Nicole Holofcener)

Other Alternates: Gravity (Alfonso Cuarón and Jonás Cuarón)

Actual Best Original Screenplay:

1.      American Hustle (Eric Warren Singer and David O. Russell) (2.5)-3

2.      Blue Jasmine (Woody Allen) (not seen)-N/A

3.      Dallas Buyers Club (Craig Borten and Melisa Wallack) (4.5)-2

4.      Her (Spike Jonze) (5)-1

5.      Nebraska (Bob Nelson) (2.5)-4

Score: 4/5

Reaction: This is a pretty bad category. Gravity, a pretty weak script, would have made this a better category, as would have Saving Mr. Banks’s sappy, schmaltz-fest. I’m sure Blue Jasmine and Her are good, but they cannot save this category from the terribleness in the room, American Hustle and Nebraska.

Of the films nominated in these 8 major categories, I still must see Captain Phillips and Her, both of which I hope to see this weekend, as well as Blue Jasmine, August: Osage County, and Before Midnight.

As I said, I will probably get the rest of the categories out tomorrow. At the end of that, I will do some sort of summation where I discuss overall goods, bads, and uglies (I think most people know where that one will lead). Until then, good night, and good luck.

Oscar Nomination Predictions 2013

Oscar nominations come out in the morning at 8:30 Eastern/5:30 Pacific, so I will be up at 7:15 or so in order to watch the announcement.

Anyway, here are my predictions for every single category.

All of my predictions are in order of likelihood, especially further down the list in each category:

Best Picture:

1.      12 Years a Slave

2.      Gravity

3.      American Hustle

4.      The Wolf of Wall Street

5.      Nebraska

6.      Saving Mr. Banks

7.      Captain Phillips

8.      Her

9.      Inside Llewyn Davis

10.  Dallas Buyers Club

First Ones In: Blue Jasmine; August: Osage County

Other Alternates: Philomena; Before Midnight

Thoughts: I am pretty much 100% confident that the first 7 will be nominated. If the Academy continues their trend of 9 nominees instead of 10, then I hope Dallas Buyers gets in ahead of Inside Llewyn Davis, even though Davis was very good.

Best Director:

1.      Steve McQueen for 12 Years a Slave

2.      Alfonso Cuarón for Gravity

3.      Martin Scorsese for The Wolf of Wall Street

4.      Paul Greengrass for Captain Phillips

5.      David O. Russell for American Hustle

First One In: Alexander Payne for Nebraska

Other Alternates: Spike Jonze for Her; Woody Allen for Blue Jasmine; J.C. Chandor for All Is Lost

Thoughts: The first 3 are virtual locks, and Greengrass is pretty much a lock too. I thought both Russell’s and Payne’s directorial efforts were sub-par, but they’re definitely the two people duking it out for that 5^th spot.

Best Actor:

1.      Chiwetel Ejiofor in 12 Years a Slave

2.      Matthew McConaughey in Dallas Buyers Club

3.      Tom Hanks in Captain Hanks

4.      Bruce Dern in Nebraska

5.      Robert Redford in All Is Lost

First One In: Christian Bale in American Hustle

Second One In: Leonardo DiCaprio in The Wolf of Wall Street

Third One In: Oscar Isaac in Inside Llewyn Davis

Other Alternates: Joaquin Phoenix in Her; Michael B. Jordan in Fruitvale Station; Forest Whitaker in Lee Daniels’ The Butler

Thoughts: As long as Bale doesn’t get nominated, I will be happy. I would love for DiCaprio or Isaac to get on instead of the good-but-not-great Dern, but that doesn’t seem all that likely. So I’m going with the consensus prediction and hoping that American Hustle gets as little love as possible.

Best Actress:

1.      Cate Blanchett in Blue Jasmine

2.      Sandra Bullock in Gravity

3.      Emma Thompson in Saving Mr. Banks

4.      Judi Dench in Philomena

5.      Meryl Streep in August: Osage County

First One In: Amy Adams in American Hustle

Other Alternates: Brie Larson in Short Term 12; Adèle Exarchopoulos in Blue Is the Warmest Colour; Julie Delpy in Before Midnight

Thoughts: This seems to be the most set-in-stone category in recent years, which is not really necessarily a good thing. I liked Thompson more than most, but was very underwhelmed by Dench. I haven’t seen Blanchett, but I doubt I’d dislike her. I also haven’t seen Streep, but I figure she’s just doing Streep. I hope the Academy decides to broaden its horizons with Larson, Exarchopoulos, or Delpy, but I know it won’t. Also, while I did think Adams was decent, I don’t think she’s worthy. Also, why is Julia Roberts a supporting actress in August? I know she isn’t and I haven’t even seen it. What’s the deal with not recognizing brilliant voice work? Kristen Bell should 100% be in the conversation and she’s nowhere close.

Best Supporting Actor:

1.      Jared Leto in Dallas Buyers Club

2.      Michael Fassbender in 12 Years a Slave

3.      Barkhad Abdi in Captain Phillips

4.      Daniel Brühl in Rush

5.      James Gandolfini in Enough Said

First One In: Bradley Cooper in American Hustle

Second One In: Tom Hanks in Saving Mr. Banks

Third One In: Jonah Hill in The Wolf of Wall Street

Other Alternates: nobody really

Thoughts: This is a fascinating category in my opinion. It has the potential, if my predictions are correct, to have 0 total Oscar nominations in it. That being said, Gandolfini is at risk to Cooper, who has 1 and was horrendous in his movie, and, despite their great success, either Abdi and Brühl could be replaced by Hanks. Anybody but Cooper, anybody but Cooper, anybody but Cooper, anybody but Cooper.

Best Supporting Actress:

1.      Lupita Nyong’o in 12 Years a Slave

2.      Jennifer Lawrence in American Hustle

3.      Julia Roberts in August: Osage County

4.      June Squibb in Nebraska

5.      Sally Hawkins in Blue Jasmine

First One In: Oprah Winfrey in Lee Daniels’ The Butler

Other Alternates: nobody, but there should be, especially Sarah Paulson and Alfre Woodard in 12 Years, Carey Mulligan in Inside Llewyn, Jennifer Garner in Dallas Buyers, and Margot Robbie in The Wolf.

Thoughts: What a dreadfully weak category. This is always a weak category, but damn, this is bad. Going for Hawkins and not Winfrey is a real leap of faith, but I would prefer a stronger category.

Best Adapted Screenplay:

1.      12 Years a Slave (John Ridley)

2.      The Wolf of Wall Street (Terence Winter)

3.      Philomena (Steve Coogan and Jeff Pope)

4.      Captain Phillips (Billy Ray)

5.      Before Midnight (Richard Linklater, Ethan Hawke, and Julie Delpy)

First One In: August: Osage County (Tracy Letts)

Other Alternates: Second One In: Lone Survivor (Peter Berg)

Thoughts: This is a strong category. 12 Years, Wolf, and Philomena are all very strong scripts, and I’ve also heard great things about Captain Phillips and Before Midnight. Lone Survivor is a major long-shot, and August: Osage County’s script just got some bad reviews, but it’s a definite threat to make it instead of Before Midnight.

Best Original Screenplay:

1.      American Hustle (Eric Warren Singer and David O. Russell)

2.      Her (Spike Jonze)

3.      Blue Jasmine (Woody Allen)

4.      Inside Llewyn Davis (Joel and Ethan Coen)

5.      Nebraska (Bob Nelson)

First One In: Dallas Buyers Club

Second One In: Enough Said

Other Alternates: Gravity (Alfonso Cuarón and Jonás Cuarón)

Thoughts: This is also a weak category. Dallas Buyers is my favorite Original of the year (based on what I’ve seen, of course), and I did not like the screenplays to American Hustle and Nebraska, but this is almost certainly the lineup.

Best Animated Feature:

1.      Frozen

2.      The Wind Rises

3.      Monsters University

4.      Despicable Me 2

5.      Ernest and Celestine

First One In: The Croods

Other Alternates: Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2; Epic; Planes

Thoughts: Going with Ernest and Celestine instead of The Croods will, in all likelihood, come back to bite me, but they’ve surprised before with things like The Pirates! Band of Misfits, A Cat in Paris, Chico and Rita, The Illusionist, and The Secret of the Kells, so I’m hoping Ernest and Celestine with be this year’s The Triplets of Belleville.

Best Foreign Language Film:

First here’s the shortlist:

The Broken Down Circle Breakdown (Belgium)

An Episode in the Life of an Iron Picker (Bosnia and Herzegovina)

The Grandmaster (Hong Kong)

The Great Beauty (Italy)

The Hunt (Denmark)

The Missing Picture (Cambodia)

The Notebook (Hungary)

Omar (Palestine)

Two Lives (Germany)

1.      The Great Beauty (Italy)

2.      The Hunt (Denmark)

3.      The Grandmaster (Hong Kong)

4.      The Broken Down Circle Breakdown (Belgium)

5.      Omar (Palestine)

First One In: Two Lives (Germany)

Second One In: The Notebook (Hungary)

Thoughts: The Great Beauty is the run-away favorite with The Hunter a distant second. Everything else is far behind. The Grandmaster benefits from its pedigree, and while Omar is perhaps slightly less likely than Two Lives, I’m giving it the nod because it’s directed by the guy who did Paradise Now, and I think name recognition, if that even exists for Hany Abu-Assad, will make a difference over Two Lives.

Best Documentary Feature:

First here’s the shortlist:

20 Feet from Stardom

The Act of Killing

The Armstrong Lie

Blackfish

The Crash Reel

Cutie and the Boxer

Dirty Wars

First Cousin Once Removed

God Loves Uganda

Life According to Sam

Pussy Riot: A Punk Prayer

The Square

Stories We Tell

Tim’s Vermeer

Which Way Is the Front Line from Here?

1.      The Act of Killing

2.      Stories We Tell

3.      Blackfish

4.      The Square

5.      The Armstrong Lie

First One In: 20 Feet from Stardom

Other Alternates: Tim’s Vermeer

Thoughts: While I do like documentaries, I see a negligible number of them (less than 1 per year) and have no idea about what’s going to be nominated here. The Act of Killing has garnered significant praise, as has Stories We Tell. The Armstrong Lie is, evidently, a long-shot, but it seems just the type of thing they’d go for. Alex Gibney, who directed Armstrong, is also receiving a Writers’ Guild Award for his career, so I could see him making it on. 20 Feet from Stardom, which is about backup singers or something just seems really boring to me, which is why I’m not putting it on.

Best Production Design:

1.      The Great Gatsby (Catherine Martin and Beverley Dunn)

2.      12 Years a Slave (Adam Stockhausen and Alice Baker)

3.      Gravity (Andy Nicholson and Rosie Goodwin)

4.      American Hustle (Judy Becker and Heather Loeffler)

5.      The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (Dan Hennah and Ra Vincent)

First One In: Saving Mr. Banks (Michael Corenblith and Susan Benjamin)

Second One In: Oz: The Great and Powerful (Robert Stromberg and Nancy Haigh)

Other Alternates: Her (K.K. Barrett and Gene Serdena)

Thoughts: I don’t really have any opinion here, other than that The Hobbit and 12 Years should be the only ones in the conversation for the win. American Hustle was very good but not great. In case people actually care about the category, though, I should explain that it is a combination of Art Direction and Set Design. Essentially that boils down to sets and props. Every set you see in a movie was drawn by a set designer and every prop was chosen to create the time and geographical setting, etc.

Best Cinematography:

1.      Gravity (Emmanuel Lubezki)

2.      12 Years a Slave (Sean Bobbit)

3.      Inside Llewyn Davis (Bruno Delbonnel)

4.      Nebraska (Phedon Papamichael)

5.      Prisoners (Roger Deakins

First One In: Captain Phillips (Barry Ackroyd)

Second One In: Rush (Anthony Dod Mantle)

Other Alternates: none

Thoughts: Gravity and 12 Years a Slave are definite locks. Inside Llewyn Davis seems to be a lock too. So does Nebraska, even though that’s only because it’s in black-and-white. Prisoners is probably less likely than Captain Phillips and Rush, but I’m expecting the Academy to balk at Captain Phillips’s shakiness and for Deakins’ name recognition to propel him to his 10^th nomination and, eventually, his 10^th loss. If Lubezki doesn’t win this thing, it will be the biggest debacle since he lost for The Tree of Life 3 years ago.

Best Costume Design:

1.      The Great Gatsby (Catherine Martin)

2.      12 Years a Slave (Patricia Norris)

3.      American Hustle (Michael Wilkinson)

4.      Saving Mr. Banks (Daniel Orlandi)

5.      Oz: The Great and Powerful (Gary Jones)

First One In: The Invisible Woman (Michael O’Connor)

Other Alternates: The Hunger Games: Catching Fire (Trish Summerville); The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (Bob Buck, Ann Maskrey, and Richard Taylor)

Thoughts: American Hustle is more likely than Oz and Mr. Banks, and I hate that fact. I’d say this category is pretty solid, unless The Invisible Woman makes it in, which is a distinct possibility.

Best Editing:

1.      Gravity (Mark Sanger and Alfonso Cuarón)

2.      Captain Phillips (Christopher Rouse)

3.      12 Years a Slave (Joe Walker)

4.      The Wolf of Wall Street (Thelma Schoonmaker)

5.      Rush (Daniel P. Hanley and Mike Hill)

First One In: American Hustle (Jay Cassidy and Crispin Struthers)

Other Alternates: none

Thoughts: Well-made, physical thrillers are always the best bets in this category, followed by Best Picture contenders, which is why I’m insane for going with Rush instead of American Hustle, but I just didn’t like the latter, and the former fits the bill, so there we have it. I’ll probably pay for it come the morning, but I don’t care.

Best Makeup and Hairstyling:

First the shortlist:

American Hustle

Bad Grandpa

Dallas Buyers Club

The Great Gatsby

Hansel and Gretel: Witch Hunters

The Hunger Games: Catching Fire

The Lone Ranger

1.      American Hustle

2.      Dallas Buyers Club

3.      The Great Gatsby

First One In: The Hunger Games: Catching Fire

Other Alternates: The Lone Ranger

Thoughts: If Dallas Buyers isn’t nominated for this, I will flip out. If it’s not nominated for Best Picture, then, statistically, American Hustle cannot lose. If/When it does win, it quite possibly will be the film’s only worthy win.

Best Original Score:

1.      Gravity (Steven Price)

2.      12 Years a Slave (Hans Zimmer)

3.      The Book Thief (John Williams)

4.      Saving Mr. Banks (Thomas Newman)

5.      Captain Phillips (Henry Jackman)

First One In: All Is Lost (Alex Ebert)

Other Alternates: Rush (Hans Zimmer)

Thoughts: All Is Lost won‎‎’t make it in because it won the Golden Globe. On the seldom occasions when the Globes get it right, the Oscars don’t. This will be an interesting duel between Gravity and 12 Years come Oscar night. Rush is technically the second one in, but that’s incredibly unlikely. Let’s be honest: John Williams is the only guy they’d nominate twice in one year nowadays. Also, if I’m correct, then congratulations to Thomas Newman for his 12^th nomination and 12^th loss in this category.

Best Original Song:

1.      “Let It Go” from Frozen (written by Robert Lopez and Kristen Anderson-Lopez and performed by Idina Menzel (film) and Demi Lovato (credits)) (Idina’s is the best)

2.      “Ordinary Love” from Mandela: Long Walk to Freedom (written by U2 and Brian Burton and performed by U2)

3.      “Young and Beautiful” (written by Lana Del Ray and Rick Nowels and performed by Del Ray)

4.      The Moon Song (written by Karen Orzolek and Spike Jonze and performed by Karen O)

5.      Atlas (written and performed by Coldplay)

First One In: “Happy” from Despicable Me 2 (written and performed by Pharrell Williams)

Other Alternates: “I See Fire” from The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug (written and performed by Ed Sheeran); “My Lord Sunshine” from 12 Years a Slave (written by Nicholas Britell and performed by David Hughey and Roosevelt Credit)

Thoughts: It’s a huge shame “In Summer”, and “Love Is an Open Door” to a lesser extent, from Frozen weren’t shortlisted. Same with “Please Mr. Kennedy” from Inside Llewyn Davis.

Overall, I’ll probably only get the top three correct, as the music department votes incredibly oddly for this category every year. “I See Fire” didn’t really work with the movie in my opinion. I’m very happy “Ordinary Love” won the Globe because the Globes and the Oscars pretty much never match up in this category, and I want “Let It Go” to win incredibly badly.

Best Sound Editing

1.      Gravity

2.      All Is Lost

3.      Captain Phillips

4.      Rush

5.      12 Years a Slave

First One In: Lone Survivor

Other Alternates: Pacific Rim

Thoughts: Most importantly, this means sound effects editing, so things like explosions, weather phenomena, car crashes, etc. This pretty much has more to do with sound creation than anything else. Thus, Gravity, All Is Lost, and Rush are locks, as is Captain Phillips.

Sound Mixing:

1.      Gravity

2.      Captain Phillips

3.      All Is Lost

4.      12 Years a Slave

5.      Rush

First One In: Inside Llewyn Davis

Other Alternates: absolutely none

Thoughts: This is the category for sound. So how well are all of the sound tracks (speech, score, crickets chirping, etc.) put together. Inside Llewyn Davis is on the outside looking in only because the other five are so strong in this regard. Rush, though, could lose its place.

Best Visual Effects:

1.      Gravity

2.      The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug

3.      Pacific Rim

4.      Elysium

5.      Star Trek Into Darkness

First One In: Iron Man 3

Other Alternates: World War Z

Thoughts: Gravity can’t lose (apologies in advance to the excellent effects by The Hobbit’s crew), so trying to figure out who else will be nominated is just an exercise in vanity. Anyway, Elysium has the umph the Academy needs, and Iron Man 3 doesn’t seem to really be anything special. World War Z suffers because it really only has zombies (at least that’s what it looked like to me as I didn’t actually subject myself to it).

Best Animated Short:

1.      Get a Horse

2.      Room on the Broom

3.      Mr. Hublot

4.      Subconscious Password

5.      The Missing Scarf

First One In: Feral

Other Alternates: I have no idea

Thoughts: Get a Horse, which preceded Frozen, is the only one I’ve seen, and though it’s good, it’s nowhere near Flying Books from a few years ago, still the greatest short I’ve ever seen. I don’t care about the short categories at all, and from the way they nominate things in these 3 categories, it seems like Academy members don’t either.

Best Live Action Short:

1.      The Voorman Problem

2.      Tiger Boy

3.      Dva (Two)

4.      Kush

5.      Throat Song

First One In: Aquel No Era Yo (That Wasn’t Me)

Other Alternates: Drawing from a hat might serve you better.

Thoughts: The Voorman Problem will probably win as it’s based on part number9dream by David Mitchell (who also wrote Cloud Atlas) and stars Martin Freeman and Tom Hollander. Other than that, see my last sentence for Best Animated Short.

Best Documentary Short:

1.      The Lady in Number 6: Music Saved My Life

2.      Facing Fear

3.      Cavedigger

4.      Slomo

5.      Jujitsu-ing Reality

First One In: Karama Has No Walls; Prison Terminal: Last Days of Private Jack Hall

Other Alternate: Recollections (I have just included all of the shortlisted shorts)

Thoughts: I really don’t have any idea what any of these are about and will never see a single one of them.

Saving Mr. Banks, Frozen, and Nebraska

1/8/14:

Saving Mr. Banks:

Saving Mr. Banks is an interesting film, but not a great one, and arguably not an important one, either.

The film follows Walt Disney’s efforts to convince P.L. Travers to allow him to make Mary Poppins, as I think most are aware. But much of the scenes involving the script-reading, song-singing, etc. are acted standardly by Bradley Whitford, Jason Schwartzmann, and B.J. Novak and are dreadfully directed by John Lee Hancock, known best for his saccharine, yet still somehow watchable, The Blind Side. He infuses each and every scene in the cinematic present with sugary sentimentality, which it didn’t need at all because Kelly Marcel and Sue Smith’s script is perfectly fine just how it is where that’s concerned.

To elaborate, Marcel and Smith’s script isn’t fantastic, but it’s certainly strong. It may be a little sugary, but it never comes close to being overly saccharine. Its weakness is its first third to a half are too sparsely written. The film is also hurt because Hancock fails to create any sense of dramatic tension.

The technical production elements of the film are quite well done. The costuming and art direction are perfect. Thomas Newman’s score is also fascinatingly modern for a film that takes place in the 1960s and early 1900s.

Instead, it is the scenes not directly related to Travers’ script-scrapping and conversation-recording that pack the punch and compose the best parts of the film. This is surprisingly astute film that isn’t just about the making of a “Hollywood classic.” It’s also, in equal measure, about guilt and forgiveness and family and love. It’s about saving Mr. Banks, but it’s also about saving P.L. Travers from herself, from the guilt she feels about her father, whom she is unable to save, perhaps a major reason she feels the need to have Mary Poppins save Mr. Banks.

The film’s quality improves gradually, and the final third to a half is great. Much of this is due to the improving quality of the flashbacks and the increasing number of scenes involving just Emma Thompson and Tom Hanks.

Overall, the film is saved by the acting of Emma Thompson, as P.L. Travers, of Tom Hanks, as Walt Disney, and of Colin Farrell, as Travers’ father. Emma Thompson is my favorite living actress. She has this natural austerity, some might call it coldness, coupled with a remarkable ability to show humanity and vulnerability beneath the rough exterior, and it makes her perfectly cast as Travers. She utilizes her skills as an actress brilliantly, managing her entire transformation wonderfully, even when the script is somewhat lacking at her critical transformative scenes. That people don’t change all that much is a recurring theme of the film, and she works it into her character beautifully; she’s changed, transformed even, but she’s not a different person than she was before.

Tom Hanks, about whom I had qualms, fearing he was severely miscast, is a surprise. His Disney is sweet and, more importantly, sincere in his almost constant positivity. He has a couple of great scenes, but his scene with Thompson in the living room about art’s healing power is easily his best. He and Thompson share a strong chemistry, especially in the film’s second half.

Honestly, though, Colin Farrell is the unsung hero of the film, and, for the life of me, I can’t understand why nobody, and I mean nobody, is singing his praises. He is wonderful and sincere and, finally, heartbreaking. He made me feel more sympathy for Mr. Banks than David Tomlinson ever did, despite not literally portraying him.

This is a decent film, perhaps even a good, but not quite a very good one. It is a sweet film at heart that is ruined by a director who instills enough sugary badness in movies to make them diabetic.

P.S. It’s also a great film to train yourself to watch a movie critically. It’s full of connections between time periods to tie the film together. On an unrelated note, it’s also interesting that the quality improvement of the film as a whole is a rough microcosm to the gradual improvement of Travers and Disney’s relationship.

76/100

1/9/14:

Frozen:

This film is pure joy, plain and simple.

The film, written by Jennifer Lee, Chris Buck, and Shane Morris and based on Hans Christian Andersen’s fairy tale The Snow Queen, follows Elsa and Anna, the princesses of Arendelle. Elsa, however, has been gifted with the ability to create ice and snow, but it’s also a curse she struggles to control. When their parents die, Elsa is crowned, but her powers get the best of her and she retreats into self-imposed exile, simultaneously creating universal winter. Anna has to go get her to restore summer. True love and all that good stuff are also involved, as per typical Disney.

At face value, it’s not a groundbreaking storyline, with a few elements beginning in a clichéd manner. The brilliance of the screenplay, however, is in its resolution of each of these elements. Not one of the situation resolutions is as to be expected, even the act of true love necessary to save the heroine. In fact, this act is touching and raw (strange to say that about any aspect of an animated film). While the script doesn’t measure up to the height or ambition of those of 12 Years a Slave or The Wolf of Wall Street, it makes up for it by being funny and heartfelt, two qualities that help it become a film for both children and adults.

The animation is gorgeous and stylish and Christophe Beck’s score adds perfectly to every moment of the film in much the same way Alan Menken’s did in the early part of the Disney Renaissance. He will not receive the credit he is due for two reasons. One: he is not Alan Menken. Two: the score is overshadowed by the absolutely brilliant songs.

Husband-wife team Robert Lopez and Kristen Anderson-Lopez have written 8 of the best film songs in recent memory, and they will likely win the Oscar for one of them. Let It Go is a powerful song sung by one of the musical theater industry’s most powerful voices, Idina Menzel, and while its message in the film itself isn’t the greatest, the basic idea of being yourself and not letting other people get to you, is. The rest of the songs are all unique, and all have great messages. Whether it’s that we all have things about us that aren’t the best that make us special or that sometimes other people aren’t all that nice, the messages are intertwined with some of the catchiest tunes. They’re also surprisingly satisfying musically speaking.

That the film’s messages, the foremost of which is, of course, the power of love (and also of family), do not become cumbersome is a testament both to the screenplay and the film’s directors, Chris Buck and Jennifer Lee, who I’m strongly considering putting on my personal ballot in the category.

The film has incredibly realistic characters and (relatively) realistic resolutions. Its heroine is a real person as opposed to an ideal for 5-year-old girls to never living up to. Sure, she’s beautiful, but she’s spunky and smart and socially awkward and simultaneously sure and unsure of herself. She doesn’t end up with the most handsome guy, the “prince charming,” but with the other guy, though I must say that this other guy has a strange ruggedness and big-boned Scandinavian-ness that does, I assume, make his reasonably attractive. She’s exactly what animation studios have been trying to create for probably a decade: a strong female, a feminist, even.

Another one of the film’s innumerable strengths is its voice acting. As the heroine, Anna, Kristen Bell, best known as Veronica Mars, is blessed with arguably the greatest lead female character in animated film history (Belle (and possibly Ariel and Pocahontas) are her only real competition), and takes full advantage of it. She is outstanding. Despite being in an animated film, I felt as though I were almost watching her live. Every syllable, spoken and sung, matched and resonated with her character perfectly. As her sister, Elsa (the Snow Queen), Idina Menzel, best known as for originating the role of Elphaba in Wicked on Broadway, is actually heartbreaking. Her singing voice, quite frankly, is enough to have me worshipping her, but she infuses it and her speaking voice with the same dejectedness and power and, at times, incredible warmth she did as Elphaba. Finally, as a snowman named Olaf, Josh Gad, another Broadway import known for originating the role in The Book of Mormon, which also had its songs co-written by Robert Lopez, is hysterical, and, if not for the character being a snowman, he could have been Olaf in the flesh or snow, carrot, sticks, and coal or whatever.

This is easily the best pure Disney film since The Lion King and arguably the most purely enjoyable and lovable Disney film ever made.

95/100

P.S. I thought I’d include the Let It Go video just for kicks to show the brilliance of the song and of the animation.

Nebraska:

To say I thought Nebraska was anything more than slightly below average would be a lie. It was, at best, a disappointing film.

It’s an Alexander Payne character study of a disconnected man. He’s done it before: 4 times actually (you could argue 5, but it’s more of a stretch than I’m willing to make). But he co-wrote each of those films. This time, Payne’s absence on the writing credits is probably the film’s fatal flaw.

Bob Nelson’s script about a boozy Korean War vet, who’s travelling from Billings, MT to Lincoln, NE with his son because he believes himself to have won a contest for $1,000,000, can’t say no to people, and can’t wrap his head around the world that changed while he blinked, seems, more often than not, like a lesson in how not to write a script. It wants to be witty and personable and off-beat and under, with a wonderfully unexpected (but not jarring) sense of warmth and with important messages about the importance and the oddity of (extended) family, but it just isn’t. It’s rather like a Coen brothers’ movie without both the entertaining performance of the dialogue and without any of the characterization aspects of the dialogue.

The first two-thirds of the film is composed of scenes have sparse, wooden dialogue with more of a sense of caricature than humanity. There are glimpses of truth, but nothing long-lasting. Payne’s films are occasionally chastised for mocking their subjects. Here, luckily, that isn’t an issue; instead, there isn’t anything, character-wise, to mock.

Payne’s direction, unfortunately, mirrors some of the script’s shortcomings. It’s fine enough, but lacks conviction of almost any kind.

But it’s not completely bad. The film’s final act is quite a bit better than average, very good, even, but still not great. The writing shows some warmth toward the end, mixed with the off-kilter sense of humor so clearly Nelson’s goal throughout. This third act provides nearly all of the script-provided nuance of characterization.

The performances, as can be expected, suffer from the script, but they are probably the best thing about the film as a whole. Bruce Dern is lucky because he doesn’t speak much, especially early on, and does a quite good job expressing his trouble and general lack of understanding. Will Forte, who would be my favorite in the film if he was similarly silent in the film’s opening. He does his best during this period, but is unfortunately wooden. He loosens as the film progresses, though. June Squibb is given the best material and delivers accordingly, adding some emotional subtlety to her part as events progress. Her scenes in the cemetery and when returning the compressor are her best.

Phedon Papamichael’s cinematography, much praised, is nothing but standard and would be nowhere near awards talk if it weren’t in black and white.

But it can’t save the film. Now maybe I just don’t understand where the film is coming from because I’m only 20, but I stand by my criticism of it. It’s a lacking film, which is really a shame because its premise had such potential.

62/100

The Wolf of Wall Street

1/4/14:

The Wolf of Wall Street:

The Wolf of Wall Street is a terrific satire following Jordan Belfort from his first day as a Wall Street stockbroker to a brilliant, (semi-)depraved multi-millionaire to his legal and personal downfall to his rebirth.

I am a big fan of Martin Scorsese. I think it is all but impossible to dislike the majority of his films (he does have some duds) unless you are completely turned off by huge amounts of vulgarity, drug use, sexual content, and violence. Indeed, his films can be incredibly vulgar. Previously, his most vulgar movie probably was Casino, with 428 f-words in about 3 hours, followed by Goodfellas with 300 in 1.5 hours and The Departed with 237 in 1.5 hours. The Wolf of Wall Street blows all of these out of the water, making up for its essential lack of violence with 506 in 3 hours.

But despite this monstrous number and the extensive amounts of drug-use and (mainly) female nudity, The Wolf of Wall Street, though certainly seeming at least somewhat depraved at times, never seems incongruous with its vulgar elements, and even seems to require them the majority of the time. This feat is owed completely to three elements.

Some types of films can rely on their art direction, visual effects, or cinematography to make the film great, but a great satire must be blessed with a great screenplay, great direction, and great performances. The Wolf of Wall Street has all three.

Terence Winter’s (creator of Boardwalk Empire and staff writer for The Sopranos) script is brilliant. Equal parts seriousness and hilarity, it masterfully mixes them into a magnificently over-the-top, rarely, if ever, farcical, film. The final act of the film works so well because the rest of it is so satirical and not farcical. The way some of the episodes are told is brilliant (the Lamborghini scene springs to mind).

Scorsese is rightly considered one of the best directors ever, and he shows why here. Winter’s script, no matter how satirical, could have become farcical if directed incorrectly. Scorsese is no stranger to challenging projects, and directs this film brilliantly. The tone he sets throughout is simply perfect.

Scorsese movies are almost always all about the men, and Wolf is no different. Leonardo DiCaprio, in his fifth collaboration with Scorsese, gives possibly his best performance ever (The Departed is the competition). The film also could have strayed into farce if the acting had been done incorrectly. As my statement about DiCaprio’s performance indicates, this is not an issue. He is simply brilliant. He appears in probably 85% to 95% of the film, and completely dominates it every second. He is an absolute riot (his crawling scene is brilliance). He is always ACTING, but everything he does is completely believable in creating a complete and surprisingly complex character. Furthermore, his performance in the final act is startlingly powerful.

Overall, the supporting male cast is quite good, even if not truly great. Jonah Hill, as Donnie Azoff, could surprise for an Oscar nomination, and he would be more deserving here than he was for Moneyball, but he is nowhere near my top 10, even. The style he chooses doesn’t work particularly well with the film, as he seems to be underplaying many of the scenes when his usual comedic, over the top style could have worked well, especially since he seems to be going for laughs the entire time, strange given his simultaneous underplaying.

While Hill, despite his large amount of screentime, is simply acceptable (sometimes slightly better), Matthew McConaughey, with just two early scenes to his credit, is my favorite supporting male performance in the film. I love how he has reinvented himself as an actor, and his performance here, specifically in his second scene, is immensely entertaining. He gives great life to Mark Hanna in just about 10 minutes. It’s a case of terrific casting, but also of even going beyond that casting to create a great performance.

The rest of the male supporting cast is pretty good across the board. Rob Reiner is pretty funny in his first scene but is unfortunately subdued the rest of his screentime. Jean Dujardin is characteristically charming but nothing more. Kyle Chandler, who has the ability to be a great actor, is sidelined here, just as he has been since jumping from Friday Night Lights to films, to the law enforcement. His scene on the yacht shows shades of his abilities, but those abilities are never again utilized.

As with most Scorsese films, The Wolf of Wall Street treats most of its female characters (nothing more than appearances, really) as objects for male lust and sexual use. Just as with most other Scorsese film, too, there are a few (sometimes just one) female character(s) that could be considered, in some way, strong and/or complex women (i.e. Lorraine Bracco’s character in Goodfellas and Vera Farmiga’s in The Departed). Margot Robbie portrays Wolf’s, Naomi Lapaglia, very well. She’s stunning but definitely not stupid, and aware of both. Robbie gives her depth, and while she doesn’t necessarily build upon the script all that much, she makes up for it with two great scenes: the teddy bear scene and her final scene. Joanna Lumley, as Naomi’s aunt, Emma, is also pretty good.

With its huge runtime, a huge, but not unexpected plaudit must be given to longtime Scorsese collaborator Thelma Schoonmaker for her terrific editing job that makes the film feel shorter than it is (though it still does feel long). Rodrigo Prieto also deserves credit for his cinematography, as he finds new shots so that the film’s shots don’t become repetitive and boring.

All of the criticism about how it’s condoning the sort of behavior exhibited by the protagonists is absurd. The only worry is uneducated and/or unintelligent people who see the film thinking getting the wrong idea about investment. The argument that more about the victims should have been shown is equally ridiculous. This film is timely because the recession has made victims of millions of people, so many have experienced, be it first- or second-hand, the potential devastation of these terrible practices. No, the film is about exactly what it should have been about: the outrageous extravagance, selfishness, and power of the stockbrokers, nothing more than that and nothing less.

This is a brilliant satire and a monumentally entertaining affair that succeeds extraordinarily well.

94/100